Friday, November 26, 2021

Cecil Hurt

TO COMMENT ON THIS POST, PLEASE CLICK ON THE ABOVE LINK.

In the summer before the 2020 college football season, I decided to stop publishing The Commissioners Blog. Y'all will remember what life was like then. It seemed as if the country was coming apart, whether there would be a college football season was an open question. And social media was one of the many dumpster fires blazing away every day. I decided not to swim in that pool any longer...... gosh, I hope mixing my metaphors didn't trigger someone into raising a Twitter mob against me. 

In any event, I decided given what I do for a living, to give up writing The Grades was the prudent thing to do. I don't regret that decision, but I do regret not experiencing the fun of grading the performance of the 2020 Crimson Tide football team, and sharing that with the readers of this blog.

I have no training as a journalist, or sports writer. I've always admired people who are good at that difficult endeavor, and the sports writer I admired most was Cecil Hurt. 

I never had the pleasure of meeting Cecil. But, I do have the privilege of being friends with some folks who knew him well. Readers of this Blog know one of those friends as The Correspondent From The Tire Store.  The Tire Store Correspondent was my law partner for two decades and has been my friend for nearly three. 

I called The Tire Store, and asked Our Correspondent if he was willing to post a memorial tribute to Cecil Hurt. He was, and I am proud to share it with you:

I hope you had a nice Thanksgiving.

In case you missed the news over the holiday week, it is my sad duty to point out that the long-time Tuscaloosa News beat writer for Crimson Tide athletics, Cecil Hurt, has passed away.  He was 62.

I met Cecil when we were undergrads.  In addition to being in the same program (and at a time when the University student population was less than half its current size), for a time the young woman Cecil was dating happened to be best friends with the young woman who had made the questionable decision to go out with me.  Cecil and I spoke occasionally over the years.   Knowing of my connection, the Commissioner asked if I would write a little bit about Cecil.  I am honored to do so.

If you are an Alabama fan, then even if you never met Cecil, you probably somehow feel as if you knew him anyway.  Through his writing, podcasting, Twitter work, appearances on radio and television -- you felt like  you knew who he was.  And you were right.

Cecil Hurt was exactly as you would have expected if you followed his work, even just occasionally.  I remember him as delightfully unpretentious.  He always looked like he had forgotten to comb his hair, was carrying a few extra pounds (that he wasn't worrying about), and his clothing was sort of comfortably rumpled.  He was a bit surprisingly soft-spoken.  But if you were smart enough to shut up and listen to him, you would find a sharp mind, a deep knowledge of Alabama sports (especially football and basketball), and a set of sources whose trust he had earned the hard way.  Cecil was a gentleman.  In my experience he was friendly, gracious, and above all, hard-working.  On any given day he might report about a play in the last game you didn't notice, a walk-on who was making good in practice, or present an extended analogy comparing  the current season to the Punic Wars.  Sneaky-smart was Cecil.

Covering a program like Alabama seems like a dream come true to the average fan.  The job is clearly in the "Careful What You Wish For" category.   Most people only think of travelling to premier away games on the newspaper's expense account, writing and talking about football for a living, and eating free dinner in the climate-controlled press box with its premium view of the field.

 The reality is a bit more harsh.  Those were working trips.  The press box itself is a newsroom with a work desk and except for the clatter of keyboards, a relatively quiet space.   Watching the game and cheering on your team is a bit different than having to watch the game with detachment, notice the key details that people expect you to deliver, being there for warm-ups and hanging around till the end of the coach's press conference.  Then making sure your work was complete in time to land in the reading public's driveway no later than 7 a.m.  Those cool expense account trips also meant that on Sunday when a lot of people were relaxing with a cup of coffee and reading your work, you were slogging home from Baton Rouge, or Gainesville, or College Station, because there was an injury report and wrap up to write and the weekly press conference is always on Monday....  And for every thrilling LSU or Tennessee or Auburn game you get to cover, there's also a Southern Miss or North Texas State or Mississippi College of Cosmetology and Autobody Repair which requires the same effort and analysis.

Cecil's writing style set him apart.  His dissection of a game or season was spot on.  Lots of people could do that.  Cecil, however, could present that material in a way that was accessible to seasoned football insiders as well the average 5th grade fan in Gordo or Moulton.  Especially early in his career, people who do a lot of writing would just occasionally get to see the artifacts that crop up in work that has been thoughtfully written, but carefully rewritten, which is often the difference between good and great.   For work on deadline that had several steps to undergo between the final punctuation and getting tossed out of a speeding car window at 6 a.m. you could occasionally catch an extra "of" or a noun verb agreement problem.   Rereading would sometimes give a clue as to the original content of a splintery sentence that had been gone back over with plane, sandpaper, and shellac to get it where it needed to be.

Coach Saban, no particular fan of the press as you might have noticed, issued a heartfelt statement about Cecil's passing.  You've probably seen it.  More telling was a night I recall from his radio show when a caller had asked about press conferences.  Cecil happened to be the special guest that night.  Saban said, "Some people just don't have very good questions.  They just feel the need to talk. And everyone only gets one question.  I wish Cecil got to ask more questions.  He's a smart guy."  Let that simmer for a minute.

I am running out of room and still have not done my friend justice.  Perhaps an example will help.  When the NCAA decided to hand down some of the harshest penalties in its history for what were, relatively speaking, minor violations in the Alabama football program, Cecil asked what seemed to be an innocuous question.  What, he asked the apparatchik from a backwater athletic conference who was pontificating about the punishments handed down, could the University have done to be more cooperative with the NCAA as it investigated the football program.  The answer, in a moment of foolish candor was, "nothing." In fact, he allowed, Alabama had been a model of cooperation.  Yet it still was hammered.

 Cecil managed to build a series of columns around that concept.  And, in my opinion, started the now nearly complete destruction of the NCAA's investigation and enforcement procedures.  Other universities were watching closely.  The message was clear and Cecil drove it home with all the subtlety of a toss sweep to Derrick Henry -- when the NCAA comes calling, hire lawyers, hide the records, shut up, and whatever you do, don't follow Alabama's example.

And so (to borrow a phrase) we say good-bye to our gallant friend.  With all due respect to the current press corps, and there are many who cover Alabama well, I do not expect to see his equal in my lifetime.  Cecil Hurt knew more about Alabama athletics than hundreds of the rest of us combined.  He was never on the bleeding edge, but never backed away from asking hard questions or calling it like he saw it.  On Twitter, he was never shy about unsheathing his wit like a stiletto to puncture some overblown gasbag hiding behind a screen alias.

A move is afoot to have the University name the fancy new press box after Cecil.  Now, my alma mater has never missed a chance to put money in the coffers by selling naming rights.  For example, for the last building added to the ever-growing business school, the kindly mother solicited me to sponsor a study carrel.   In this case, however, perhaps the powers that be will understand the contributions Cecil has made over the years. He predates the vast majority of the current administration.  It seems to me a fitting tribute.  Cecil loved Alabama athletics so much that he was willing to tell the truth about it for nearly four decades.  I'd say the honor has been paid for and then some.  If you'd like to voice your support for that movement the University president is Dr. Stuart Bell, whom you can reach at president@ua.edu.  The athletic director does not share his email address, but you can reach him through Twitter @greg_byrne or through J Batt Senior Deputy Athletics Direct at jbatt@ia.ua.edu.

Thanks for everything, Cecil.  I'll miss your work.  Rest in peace.  Roll Tide, buddy.

The Correspondent From The Tire Store

Thursday, September 2, 2021

Hurrah. Football is here at last.

 

Happy Football Season, everyone.  From all of us down here at the Tire Store, we hope that you and your families are well.  Please be safe.  Hope to see you over in Atlanta on Saturday. It has been a long time since we last met the Hurricanes but I hope the outcome is just as satisfying.

In the meantime, please enjoy this annual reminder from the immortal Lewis Grizzard.  Roll Tide.  Beat Miami.  RIP Lewis.

 

 I was walking behind a friend and his wife as we entered the Louisiana Superdome in New Orleans on January 1, 1981, to watch Georgia play Notre Dame in the Sugar Bowl.  If Georgia won, the Bulldogs would be the 1980 national collegiate football champions.

 My friend, a fellow Georgia alumnus, was fraught with anticipation.  He was pale.  He was nervous.  He was perspiring profusely.

 ***

His wife, noticing his condition said, “Calm down sweetheart.  It’s just a football game.”

 He stopped dead.  He turned to his wife -- who had not gone to Georgia, and went to Bulldog games with her husband because she thought of it as her wifely duty -- looked her squarely in the eyes and said: “It is not just a football game.  It’s our way of life against theirs.”

 He meant that.  I knew the man well enough to know he did, in fact, mean that.

 It had something to do with Southerners against Northerners.  Maybe it even had something to with his Methodist upbringing and the pope.

 Whatever, it was clearly Us versus Them.  Us won that  day, tailback Herschel Walker leading Georgia to the national title….

 You can go into all that stuff about the pageantry of college football, the fact the players are unspoiled kids and not a bunch of millionaires, and it’s a nice way to spend an afternoon and evening with friends.

 But with me and mine, and with a lot of others, college football offers us an opportunity to circle our wagons and fight and kick and scream for our side against their side.

 I suppose that’s also possible in politics and various cultural disagreements, but all that can get a little cloudy at times.

 College football and allegiances are clear as an October Saturday afternoon.  We haven’t had a war in 50 years that wasn’t tangled up in dissent and questionable motives….  But when Georgia meets Florida, when Auburn plays Alabama, when Ohio State gathers against Michigan, there are no such nagging annoyances.

 Our way of life against theirs; clear as a bell.

 And there is the opportunity to feel proud of something. Congress can waste your money, the president can lie to you, and your kid can wear an earring and watch MTV, but if your alma mater is 8-0, who’s sweating the small stuff?

 And probably more than anything else, it also offers the opportunity to share in what is believed to be a noble cause, and such breeds friendships that can endure all else….

 College football season is the best time I live.  I once risked my life because of college football. 

 In late August of 1985 following two weeks in the Soviet Union, I found myself in a hospital in London with a deadly infection of the artificial aortic valve in my heart.  The British doctor said it would probably be necessary for me to remain there for six weeks’ treatment.

 Georgia was to open its football season on Labor Day night a week later against Alabama in Athens.  I slipped out of the hospital, caught a cab to Gatwick Airport and flew back to Atlanta. 

 When asked later why I would risk my life in such a manner, I said, “I wasn’t about to stay in no foreign country during college football season.”

 Us could win them all this year, or Us could lose a few.  But, right or wrong, win or lose, always Us.

 And Them can go to hell.  Is there any part of that that isn’t absolutely clear?

 

TO COMMENT ON THIS POST, PLEASE CLICK ON THE ABOVE LINK.

Monday, September 21, 2020

Hurrah. Football is here at last.

Well, that was a weird off season.  We hope this email finds you and yours healthy and happy.  In the face of so very many things changing for so very many people we are happy to have some things that stay everlastingly the same.  One of those is the commitment to excellence and will to win (and to prepare to do so) evidenced by so many of the young men who play football for the Alabama Crimson Tide. 

 

Just this week we saw a quote from Joshua McMillon.  Josh, you may recall, is a linebacker who patiently waited his turn in Alabama’s always-crowded-with-talent linebacking squad.  As a fifth year senior he was poised to be a starter on last year’s defense -- until he badly injured his knee in practice in August.  He has already earned his engineering degree and no one could have blamed the young man for hanging up his cleats especially going into his sixth year of the grueling work that it takes to stay in shape at this level.  Instead, he petitioned the NCAA for another year of eligibility.  A reporter asked him about his decision to return as a graduate student to play this year.  Josh said:

 

“It wasn't much going into the decision.  It was just a bad taste left in my mouth, from the past year. Going 11-2, I don't want to end my college career on a bad note like that…  It didn’t feel right leaving.” 

 

Hurray for you Josh.  We hope you love every minute of it.  So long as we have that sort of character, judgment, and appreciation for whether 11-2 is a satisfactory season or not, we are in good hands.  We are confident that attitude will make us proud of you without regard to what you do on the gridiron.

 

For those of you who may have joined late, the Commissioner indulges us each year in sending around the following work from the immortal Lewis Grizzard.  Enjoy.

 

I was walking behind a friend and his wife as we entered the Louisiana Superdome in New Orleans on January 1, 1981, to watch Georgia play Notre Dame in the Sugar Bowl.  If Georgia won, the Bulldogs would be the 1980 national collegiate football champions.

 

My friend, a fellow Georgia alumnus, was fraught with anticipation.  He was pale.  He was nervous.  He was perspiring profusely.

 

***

 

His wife, noticing his condition said, “Calm down sweetheart.  It’s just a football game.”

 

He stopped dead.  He turned to his wife -- who had not gone to Georgia, and went to Bulldog games with her husband because she thought of it as her wifely duty -- looked her squarely in the eyes and said: “It is not just a football game.  It’s our way of life against theirs.”

 

He meant that.  I knew the man well enough to know he did, in fact, mean that.

 

It had something to do with Southerners against Northerners.  Maybe it even had something to with his Methodist upbringing and the pope.

 

Whatever, it was clearly Us versus Them.  Us won that  day, tailback Herschel Walker leading Georgia to the national title….

 

You can go into all that stuff about the pageantry of college football, the fact the players are unspoiled kids and not a bunch of millionaires, and it’s a nice way to spend an afternoon and evening with friends.

 

But with me and mine, and with a lot of others, college football offers us an opportunity to circle our wagons and fight and kick and scream for our side against their side.

 

I suppose that’s also possible in politics and various cultural disagreements, but all that can get a little cloudy at times.

 

College football and allegiances are clear as an October Saturday afternoon.  We haven’t had a war in 50 years that wasn’t tangled up in dissent and questionable motives….  But when Georgia meets Florida, when Auburn plays Alabama, when Ohio State gathers against Michigan, there are no such nagging annoyances.

 

Our way of life against theirs; clear as a bell.

 

And there is the opportunity to feel proud of something. Congress can waste your money, the president can lie to you, and your kid can wear an earring and watch MTV, but if your alma mater is 8-0, who’s sweating the small stuff?

 

And probably more than anything else, it also offers the opportunity to share in what is believed to be a noble cause, and such breeds friendships that can endure all else….

 

College football season is the best time I live.  I once risked my life because of college football. 

 

In late August of 1985 following two weeks in the Soviet Union, I found myself in a hospital in London with a deadly infection of the artificial aortic valve in my heart.  The British doctor said it would probably be necessary for me to remain there for six weeks’ treatment.

 

Georgia was to open its football season on Labor Day night a week later against Alabama in Athens.  I slipped out of the hospital, caught a cab to Gatwick Airport and flew back to Atlanta. 

 

When asked later why I would risk my life in such a manner, I said, “I wasn’t about to stay in no foreign country during college football season.”

 

Us could win them all this year, or Us could lose a few.  But, right or wrong, win or lose, always Us.

 

And Them can go to hell.  Is there any part of that that isn’t absolutely clear?

 

This should be an exciting season.  We have many returning starters at key positions, promising newcomers, a reconfigured coaching staff, and (we hope) a burning desire for  a championship.  Just like last year.  I know, because I said almost the exact same thing last year at this point.

 

For those of you lucky enough to be traveling to Orlando for Saturday’s game (or anywhere else), we wish you Godspeed.  This stands to be an exciting season.  You don’t want to miss any of it.  I’m proud to share in this “noble cause” with you, my friends.

 

RIP, Lewis.  We miss you.  Roll Tide, everyone.  Beat Missouri.

 

 

TO COMMENT ON THIS POST, PLEASE CLICK ON THE ABOVE LINK.

Sunday, December 1, 2019

Iron Bowl Grades



Discipline. 

According to Coach Saban, the central importance of discipline is the lesson to be learned from the bitter end of the 2019 Alabama football season. How having it is the key to being successful, and how the lack of it is an infection that will eventually contaminate all around you.

Lack of football discipline manifests itself statistically in penalties. The Tide’s lack of discipline was on full display in Alabama’s 45-48 loss to Auburn. Bama was penalized 13 times for a collective loss of 96 yards. Five Auburn first downs resulted from Alabama penalties, the most galling of which has to be the illegal substitution penalty at the end of the game allowing Auburn to retain possession instead of punting from its own 26 yard line.

That penalty kept Alabama from having one last chance to score and maybe win the game. But a much earlier penalty on Bama's first possession of the game-offensive holding on Alex Leatherwood-negated what would have been a 37 yard touchdown pass from Mac Jones to Henry Ruggs, III. The drive ended with a field goal, so the penalty cost Alabama four points in a game it lost by three.

So, how does the 2019 Crimson Tide stack up to its most recent predecessors in this critical measure of discipline?

Over the twelve games of this season, Alabama has been penalized 90 times for 830 yards, and has allowed opponents to convert a third down by penalty 31 times [Auburn accounts for 5 of those 31 possession-down conversions]. The 2018 team, over fifteen games was penalized 87 times for 796 yards, and surrendered 29 first down conversion by penalty. The 2017 squad-the last to win a National Championship-was penalized a total of only 69 times for 569 yards, and allowed only 25 first downs by penalty.

Discipline, or the lack thereof, is also reflected in the on-field behavior of team leaders. A disciplined leader separates his teammate from the fray to avoid a penalty. A leader lacking in discipline substitutes himself for the teammate and more often than not draws a penalty.

Yes. Alabama has been riddled with injuries. Yes. Alabama has lost key talent to the NFL [I wrote everything I have to say on that topic last week.] But Alabama lost the 2019 Iron Bowl, and forfeited any chance of returning to the College Football Playoff, because they lacked discipline.

Coach Saban was not referring only to discipline in games. His critique was much broader. He implied Alabama has not disciplined in practice, in the film room, in the weight room. Against teams of lesser talent, an undisciplined effort can still result in victory. Against better competition? Look at the record: the 2019 Crimson Tide was winless against their two best opponents.

What makes the 2019 Iron Bowl result even harder to bear is the undeniable fact Alabama ought to have won the game comfortably. The objective statistics tell the story: Total yards-Alabama 515, AU 354; First Downs-Tide 28, Tigers 23; Time of Possession-Bama 35:52, Barn 24:08; Touchdowns-UA 6, Auburn 5.

Alabama had one non-offensive TD-Jaylen Waddle’s kick return-Auburn had two-interception returns [one from the Auburn end zone]. In other words, Alabama’s offense scored nearly twice as many touchdowns as did Auburn’s offense.

Here are two more stats that tells so much about the course of this game: Squandered Points [scoring opportunities lost to error]: Alabama 11, Auburn 0; Points allowed off turnovers: Alabama 14; Auburn 7.

Because whatever post-season game Alabama is invited to will be meaningless, and the only benefit of an invitation at all is December practice to work on fundamentals, I have a suggestion for a better way to spend the time and reward the fans with a game Alabama is guaranteed to win: Instead of playing Virginia, or Boise State, why not have a December A-Day game? …. But I forget, doing something like that to actually help the team improve will violate multiple NCAA rules; and we all know the NCAA is all about the Best Interests of The Student Athletes.

I will forego any discussion of the extra time out awarded to Auburn at the end of the fist half. Dissecting what laughably passes for “officiating” is the special remit of Our Correspondent From The Tire Store. This post is about grading the performance of the team, and this game is challenging enough, I do not have band width to include a critique of the Zebras.

The statistics tell one story. The result of the game tells another. So, I will grade the game as objectively as possible, then adjust for results. With that in mind, here is how I grade the game:

Offense:                      C+                   I’ve already recited the total yards and first downs. Mac Jones ran the offense quite well, completing 26 of his 39 pass attempts for 335 yards and 4 TDs [Jaylen Waddle (3); Henry Ruggs, III (1)].

Ruggs was Alabama’s leading receiver with 99 yards on 6 catches. Waddle gained 98 yards on 4 receptions. DeVonta Smith caught 5 passes for 80 yards. Jerry Jeudy also caught 5 passes gaining 26 yards. Six different receivers caught passes; officially Mac caught his own pass when one attempt was batted back to him by an on-rushing Auburn defender. I am not including his boomerang catch in the total for all receivers.

Najee Harris was fantastic. He gained 146 net yards rushing on 27 runs. Mac Jones showed his toughness and competitive drive gaining 32 net yards on 8 runs, including a 4th down pick up of 18 yards to give Alabama a chance to tie the game late.

The offense had seven possessions that gained 40 or more yards [55, 75, 62, 74, 63, 90, 52] resulting in 4 TDs, 1 FG, 1 Int, and 1 Missed FG Att.

What would otherwise have been an A+ performance is downgraded to C+ to account for the turnovers. That C+ grade is further adjusted for overall results to: F

Defense:          C                     Auburn gained 354 yards total offense [181 net rushing] and earned 23 first downs. The defense limited Auburn to only three drives of 40 or more yards [50,75, 77] resulting in 2 TDs and 1 FG. From a scoring perspective the Defense allowed Auburn 34 points.

Xavier McKinney was the co-leader among defenders with 8 tackles [7 solo]. Raekwon Davis-returning from injury-also made 8 tackles [7 solo]. Shane Lee made 7 tackles, and Anfernee Jennings made 6. In total, Tide defenders made 4 tackles for lost yardage and forced 3 fumbles. Christian Harris made Bama’s lone fumble recovery.

Auburn’s success in the passing game came, in part, from some outstanding plays by Tiger receivers making one-handed catches in tight coverage. At least three times, Bo Nix was rescued from bad throws by highlight reel catches.

What could have been an A-quality performance by the Defense is downgraded two letter grades for penalties, especially those allowing Auburn to extend drives. On two of Auburn’s three sustained drives, Alabama was flagged for a major infraction [Pass Interference; Roughing the Passer]. Therefore, the performance grade is the stated C. That grade is further adjusted for overall results to: F

Special Teams:

Kickoffs:         A                     Joe Bulovas averaged 47 yards per kick on 8 kickoffs. The coverage team allowed 3 returns for a total of 48 yards. Jaylen Waddle’s 98-yard kick return for a touchdown was spectacular. He and Trevon Diggs combined for a total of 177 yards returning Auburn kicks.

Punting:           C+                   Ty Perine punted 3 times for an average of 45 yards per punt.  Alabama had no opportunity to return an AU punt, and the coverage team allowed Auburn’s Christian Tutt two returns for a total of 47 yards.

Place Kicking:             D         Bulovas was successful on all PAT attempts and was 50% on FG attempts. He kicked the ball into the left upright at the end of the game thereby failing to tie the score at 48.

Special Teams aggregate grade of C is further adjusted for overall results to: F

Coaching:                    F          Play calling inside the red zone, particularly in “and goal” situations was unproductive. Why we do not have a “Jumbo Package” remains a mystery. The coaches have to take responsibility for the 13 penalties, especially number 13 on the day; illegal substitution giving Auburn a first down and the opportunity to kill the clock instead of having to punt from the AU 26. I know there was some malpractice on the part of the officials but the only people in the Western Hemisphere who thought Auburn intended to run a play in that situation were members of the Alabama coaching staff.

Discipline is a good thing. With it, one can achieve a standard of performance from which good results follow. Without it, even one who possesses greater talent must depend on chance or fortune for success. Remember the fable of the Tortoise and the Hare. The speedy Hare sprinted ahead of the Tortoise, but lost the race because the Tortoise had the discipline to keep going, while the Hare took a nap.

In football terms, the team with players disciplined to execute their assignments will have the opportunity to defeat a team of more talented players who lack the discipline to play as a team. When Coach Saban arrived in Tuscaloosa in 2007 he famously told reporters at his introductory presser that he wanted Alabama to be the kind of team that “other teams hate to play.” Not because they will be chippy, dirty, or even more talented; but because they will be relentless, and disciplined competitors.

The three-year trend line of penalties indicates the 2019 class has been on a downward arc in discipline. Hopefully, that downward arc hit rock bottom on Pat Dye Field last night. I for one can imagine no loss more dispiriting. I genuinely do not care whether we outscore whatever barely bowl eligible opponent we face on New Year’s Day. The result of that game is meaningless. What matters is whether the men in crimson jerseys play with discipline. Let’s start with that, and let the results take care of themselves.

A return to discipline in The Process is essential. Coach Saban undoubtedly knows this, and anyone listening to his post-game remarks should pay attention. And if you work for Coach Saban, you need to match your personal work habits to the standard of discipline Saban expects from the players. Surrounding oneself with good, hard-working, disciplined people is part of The Process. Getting shed of those who are not, is in The Process as well.

This will be the last edition of The Grades for the 2019 season. I look forward to a final report from The Tire Store.

Until next season, thank you for reading this blog. And thanks to all the Correspondents whose valuable contributions, and willingness to step in when needed, I could not do without.

Roll Tide, Y’all.  



The Commissioner

TO COMMENT ON THIS POST, PLEASE CLICK ON THE ABOVE LINK.