Sunday, September 8, 2019

New Mexico State Grades

                The official temperature in Bryant-Denny Stadium at kickoff was 94 degrees. That’s hot, but all evidence suggests it felt hotter. The media events room is airconditioned. All evidence suggests the press conference got hotter than the playing surface at kickoff when some reporter asked Coach Saban why Alabama played teams like New Mexico State. “We will play anybody who will play us,” Saban replied, then invited the reporter to “call around” and see if he can find a team willing to play Alabama. “We’ll play anybody you find who will play us!”

            Among current coaches, Saban is alone in advocating for a regular season of 10 conference games and 2 from other Power Five conferences. He listed the advantages: more excitement for fans, greater competitive challenge for players, and a clearer path to the playoffs for teams suffering a loss during the season. Because his is a solo voice on this topic, Saban has to coach within the system as it exists. This means New Mexico State, The Citadel, Charleston Southern, and similar FCS teams get to play Payday Games before 100,000 fans of FBS schools.

            This is not to suggest such opponents provide no benefits for the host teams. As Saban pointed out while roasting Saturday’s unwary reporter, the host team has an opportunity to get better and younger players have the chance for game-time experience. Saban was clearly frustrated with what he perceived to be some missed opportunities by his team in the game just completed.

            The 62-10 score is a little misleading. Yes, Alabama compiled over 600 yards of total offense, including 318 yards rushing, but the play of the offensive line was inconsistent, and the running stats were skewed by 75 yards gained by Henry Ruggs, III who took a swing pass for a touchdown on the game’s opening play. The play was classified as a run, because the pass was completed one yard up-field from where Tua threw the pass.

            Both the first and second team centers were unavailable for the game, and it showed. Several times a high or wide snap disrupted the timing of plays, and blocking assignments did not always appear to be clearly understood.

            The defense played well-enough for more than three quarters. When less-experienced players were substituted into the game however, Tide defenders had trouble executing. Consequently, the Aggies scored more points against Alabama than they did against Washington State on week one.  
  
            Special teams were a bright spot. Every kickoff was a touchback, and Will Reichard kicked two absolutely perfect field goals [49, 48] that would have been good from a much greater distance. Jaylen Waddle had a punt return touchdown nullified by a legitimate blocking infraction, but he is a spectacular player.

            In once sense it was a perfect game. Alabama won convincingly, showed some improvement in a few critical areas, but made enough mistakes to give the coaching staff lots to work on.
The quality of the opponent requires a full letter grade deduction on offense and defense. So, with that in mind here is how I grade the game:

Offense:                      B                     The offense gained 603 total net yards [318 rushing], earned 23 first downs, converted 8 or 15 possession plays [14 third downs], possessed the ball for 27:57, and did not suffer a turnover. Tua completed 16 of 24 pass attempts for 227 yards and 3 TDs [Jerry Jeudy (2); Henry Ruggs, III]. Early in the game, it appeared to me that Tua’s passes were a bit late, and slightly less accurate than we have become used to. Because Bama’s receivers are the best group of their kind in college football, some passes that might otherwise have been incomplete were salvaged. At any rate, from the second quarter on whatever might have been affecting Tua’s passing seemed to have been corrected. Mac Jones attempted 9 passes, completing 5, for 58 yards and a TD [Jeudy].

Jeudy led all receivers with 8 catches for 103 yards and 3 TDs. Ruggs caught 4 passes for 66 yards. Jaylen Waddle gained 52 yards on 2 receptions, and DeVonta Smith caught 5 passes for 47 yards. Six different players caught passes including walk-on TE Giles Amos [Sr. 6-4, 245; Perry, GA].

The Tide’s leading rusher was true freshman, Keilan Robinson [5-9, 184; Washington, D.C./St. John’s] who scored a 74 yard touchdown on his first play in the contest. Henry Ruggs, III’s 75 yard TD was scored as a rushing play. Najee Harris gained 68 net yards rushing on 12 runs and scored a rushing TD. Brian Robinson, Jr. carried the ball 11 times for 57 net yards. Tua scored a rushing TD from 25 yards out and totaled 33 yards rushing on his two total carries.

Alabama mounted eight drives that gained 40 or more yards [75, 89, 50, 72, 84, 55, 70, 74] and each resulted in a touchdown. Bama made three trips into the red zone and scored touchdowns each time. 

Both of Alabama’s 4th quarter offensive possessions resulted in punts following only 3 plays. Likewise, the first-team offense suffered two “three-and-out” possessions in the first half. Consequently, the + is simply not an available grade.


Defense:                      B-                    The Aggies were able to gain 262 yards of total offense [101 rushing], made 14 first downs, and converted 4 of 15 possession downs. In the fourth quarter, State dominated the Alabama defense, gaining 99 yards on 20 plays, and controlled the clock for 9:47 of the quarter. Coach Saban was none too happy about this. In post-game remarks, he singled out the defensive performance in the 4th quarter as an example of players not playing the way they have been taught in practice.

Xavier McKinney was the Tide’s leading tackler with 6 stops [5 solo]. Raekwon Davis also recorded 6 tackles [1 solo]. Jordan Battle [Fr. DB; 6-1, 201; Fort Lauderdale, FL] and fellow true freshman Shane Lee each recorded 5 tackles.

In total, the defense made 7 tackles for loss [31 yds]; forced 3 fumbles, recovered 2 fumbles [Shane Lee, Josh Jobe] intercepted a pass [Patrick Surtain] broke up 3 passes, and hurried the Aggie QB 8 times.

Special Teams:

Kickoffs:         A         Will Reichard kicked off 10 times for an average of 64 yards per kick. Nine of his kicks were touchbacks, one sailed out of bounds. Joseph Bulovas kicked off once for 40 yards. Henry Ruggs, III made one kick return for 19 yards.

Punting:           A-        Skyler DeLong punted 3 times for an average of 41 yards. Reichard punted once for 39 yards. The coverage team allowed only a single return for 1 yard. The return team was penalized for a blocking infraction that nullified Jaylen Waddle’s TD return. Otherwise, Waddle returned 3 State punts for 28 yards. His longest return gained 23 yards, but involved running from outside the numbers where he made the catch, completely across the field to the opposite side line, then reversing his field and crossing back over to the original side of the field and going out of bounds 23 yards down field from where he caught the ball in the first place.

Place Kicking:             A+                   Reichard was good from 49 and 48 on his two FG attempts and perfect on each of 10 PATs.

Coaching:                    A                     The participation report lists 66 players who saw action in the game. Alabama was penalized 4 times for 35 yards. I almost gave the coaches a minus for the decision to play Tua to start the second half with the score 38-0. I understand the importance of game time experience, but the risk/return equation eventually signals that the person getting experience in the game ought to be the back-up QB.

            Much like last week’s contest against Duke, Bama soundly defeated an inferior team. The outcome of the game was never in doubt. Still, the offensive line is unsettled, and inconsistency of execution resulting from a lack of attention to detail are things to worry about.

            With two weeks in the books, there are some things around the league coming into focus: LSU is a much-improved football team with a potent offense. The Bengal Tigers have found the QB they have been looking for and he is a stone-cold competitor. In the SEC East, Tennessee is …. Uh …. The Vols are ….  Well, Georgia is certainly playing well so far.

            But the most important game of the season is this coming Saturday in Columbia, South Carolina. We have not played the Fighting Chickens since 2010. Readers of this blog will remember that game. It is seared into our memory. Stephen Garcia had the game of his life leading South Carolina to a 35-21 victory over Alabama. It was the first loss in the season following the ’09 BCS Championship triumph over Texas in Pasadena. A victory this coming Saturday will place Alabama in the unique position of having won the most recent meeting between every other school in the SEC.

            While Alabama was beating New Mexico State on Saturday, South Carolina was dispatching Charleston Southern 72-10. The Yard Birds’ opening week loss to North Carolina may not be as big an embarrassment as some thought at the time; the Tar Heels defeated the Miami Hurricanes 28-25 yesterday.

            So, turn the heat up under a skillet of peanut oil. It’s time to fry some chicken!

Roll Tide, Y’all.


The Commissioner

TO COMMENT ON THIS POST, PLEASE CLICK ON THE ABOVE LINK.

Tuesday, September 3, 2019

Tire Store Report -- Duke

It’s so nice to have college football back.  Partly, the excitement of the return of the season is the return of The Grades.  Nice to see you already in mid-season form, Commissioner.

For a long set of complicated reasons that I’m sure we down here at the Tire Store really couldn’t understand, the ACC decided that its representative in the Chick Fil A kickoff game this season would be the Duke Blue Devils.  Now, we expect one of the factors was, you know, money, which we do like to think we have a handle on, but we’re sure there are others.

Without regard to the precise reason or reasons, Duke was the opponent on Saturday night.  Alabama and Duke have some limited amount of football history, handled in a not very coherent fashion by ABC, more below.  Duke’s coach, David Cutcliffe, is a wily old bird and how he has not managed to end up as head coach of a somewhat larger institution is sort of mystifying.  He is a pretty good recruiter, a decent motivator, and an acknowledged leader in play-design and working to exploit his opponent’s weaknesses.

We will add a few comments to the Commissioner’s excellent review of the game.

Offense:  The running game needs some work.  Duke has a veteran defensive line that was in position to make plays in the running game most of the night.  The Alabama offensive line was reportedly a mix-n-match operation throughout Fall Camp and some of that continued in the game.  Shifting personnel certainly shoulders some of the blame for a weak run game.  So does the fact that two of our running backs ended up suspended for the first quarter.  And it did appear to us a couple of times that the offensive line actually did a good job blocking at the point of attack and the running back then chose to, um, adjust the play to a different point of attack of his liking, which didn’t help.  In addition, one of last year’s starters will not be available for three more games and we are uncertain how his return will alter the picture.  Whatever.  We look for a lot of those things to be cleaned up over the next few weeks.

The passing game more than made up for weakness in the running game.  Tight end, a position generally agreed to be a major question mark entering the season, accounted for two touchdowns.  Tagovailoa mostly made excellent decisions all night and was only sacked once (he was pressured more than that, but made a nifty run to pick up a first down on a scramble -- an underappreciated part of his game).  It appeared that Duke’s strategy was “we are going to make you beat us by Alabama beat us by allowing short passes and challenging you to make sustained drives and not letting your receivers beat us deep”.  OK.  Challenge accepted.  And, we expect other defensive coordinators to try to follow suit.  As long as this outstanding group of WRs stay healthy, the tight ends continue to be involved, and the quarterback is willing to take what the defense is giving them, that should work out just fine for Alabama.

Speaking of the first-string quarterback, we noted that his exceptional play has become so routine that it hardly merits a mention by the media any longer.  In fact, we seemed to hear a lot more about Clemson’s quarterback this weekend, whose QBR was not in the top 50 on Saturday.

Defense:  The defense played an outstanding game.  In particular, the interior was manned by a true freshman nose guard and two true freshman inside linebackers.  You wouldn’t have known it by their play.  Even when Duke trotted out offensive formations/systems that Alabama could not possibly have prepared for, the defense was mostly solid.  The stop in the red zone early in the game set a tone that continued throughout the contest.  If this group can stay healthy we think it has the potential to be very special. 

Special teams:  WE KICKED OFF THE FOOTBALL INTO THE DADGUM END ZONE.  That was enough to keep us happy down here at the Tire Store.  Punting wasn’t perfect, but we only punted twice all night and we are ok if that is also a trend for the season.  PATs were perfect, though having that particular holder out there gives us some indigestion.  We did doink long-ish field goals off of both uprights (which ought to be worth something in scoring system, it seems like.)  However, regular readers know that we think missed field goals over about 45 yards aren’t the fault of the kicker so much as the coaching and offense for not being a bit closer.  It looked to us like in both cases the kicks would have been good where they crossed the goal line.  And at least we are improved from the last couple of years where it was on PATs that we were shaking the poles.  The jury, as they say, is out but we feeling some optimism.

Coaching: We had a LOT of new coaches on the field and in the pressbox Saturday afternoon.  The team seemed ready to play and anxious to get into a game, even if the opponent was not the highly-ranked foe of previous seasons.  Even so, it took some fortitude on the part of the coaches to suspend the #1 running back.  And the #2 running back.  With the #3 running back lost for the season to injury, that should send a good message to the team that no one is above the law.  Throw in the team’s best edge rusher and a starting wide receiver and we expect the message came through loud and clear.  Next time there is a team movie, we’ll expect that everyone will be in his seat before the previews of coming attractions begin.  The in-game adjustments seemed effective, especially on the offensive side of the ball.  The Defense appeared more coherent overall.  A good day.

Officials:  Well, it is nice to be reminded, I suppose, that incompetent officiating isn’t limited to our conference.  The head coach got the first penalty flag we can remember being thrown on him.  Supposedly this had to do with his displeasure at a sideline warning flag after an interception.  Our guess is that his tirade was really not so much about the sideline warning as it was just cumulative.  He was clearly unhappy when an Alabama touchdown was taken off the board on a review that stretched the boundaries of indisputable evidence thinner than a penalty flag.  He was even more unhappy about a questionable holding call away from the play on a big run.  The second pass interference call of the night was flagged from thirty yards away by the official with about the third-best look at the action.  So, yeah, by the time that flag went up in the air, Coach was ready to give someone an idea of what he thought.  Now, if he had known one of his assistants was the one who was called and that he actually did run into the official, he might have been a little less distraught, but we think that was just a 15-yarder over about five iffy calls, so at three yards per, that seems like pretty good value. The coach took responsibility for the penalty and more or less apologized.  I doubt anyone reading this space much disagreed with him being upset, however.  And, it can’t hurt to have your players reminded on national television in a very visible way that you have their backs.

Broadcast:  We don’t have many games on ABC (not counting ESPN, which is sort of owned by ABC, or well, Disney, well, never mind….)  After Saturday, I’m not too sad about that.  A couple of examples should suffice.  The sidelong remark that Alabama’s turnover belt was some kind of new invention copying Miami’s turnover chain was the sort of throwaway comment by an announcer that he thinks little of making, but for real fans of the team show how disconnected and ignorant he is of the team and its traditions.  More importantly, we were disappointed that the last several minutes of game time devolved into completely ignoring the action on the field in favor of a bunch of banter and blather between the announcers about one of them, their NFL career, draft positioning, etc.  Whoop de doo. We got used to the idea a long time ago that many football announcers have decided that their commentary was the primary reason the game was being held, rather than the other way around.  But we feel sorry for the family, friends, high school coaches, and others who are cheering for second and third string players who enter the game at the end, are fighting just as hard as those ahead of them in the starting rotation, and who deserve to have their names and numbers called for their efforts. 

So, on to game two.  We’ll be honest, when the 2019 schedule was announced, this was the opponent that most left us scratching our heads.  On paper, this is a major mismatch.  However, it is unnecessary to hark back to Coach Stallings’ warning about a game not being big till you lose it.  The coaches can just show the players a few clips from this past Saturday in Knoxville.

Roll Tide.  Beat the Aggies.