Citadel Grades

Why do the Alabama’s of the college football world play programs like the Citadel? Why does Auburn play Liberty University?

There really is no good reason for it. What is there to gain? So you beat a non-FBS opponent 50-17, what do you get out of it? Experience defending against the triple option? Nobody in the SEC runs the triple option. Getting your younger players some game experience? This was week 12, if you don’t know who can play, the weekend before the Iron Bowl is too late to start finding out. Covering the spread and not getting anyone seriously injured are about the only goals one can reasonably set for such a lopsided contest.

There surely are some people who were delighted Alabama played the military college of South Carolina. No doubt a pickup bed full of Villagers rolled Toomer’s Corner when they learned the score at the half was tied at 10.

During intermission, Coach Saban reminded the team that none of the players on the Bulldog squad could make the Tide roster. From all press accounts, Saban did not scorch the paint off the locker room walls at half time. He pointed out what everyone knew, the position coaches made adjustments, and the players, especially one of the more vocal leaders on the defense, Anfernee Jennings, took over from there. 

Alabama opened the second half with a fumble on the kick return and gave the Pups excellent field position. The Tide Defense forced a longish field goal attempt which failed to score. From that point forward, with one blown assignment on defense, and two botched PAT tries, the second half was “Built by Bama.”

Tua threw for two TDs. Irv Smith, Jr. caught a pass in the middle of the field and juked a would be tackler in a scoring play that should be featured in this week’s edition of “Mama, there go my ankles.” Jalen returned to action to the delight of the crowd, and found DeVonta Smith in the end zone for a score. The defense turned in another Non Offensive Touchdown with an 18 yard scoop and score [Anfernee Jennings].

 In the first half the team was suffering from a bad dose of rat poison.  Because it might prove to be a rat poison antidote, here is how I grade the game [automatic one whole letter grade reduction for quality of opponent]:

Offense:          C+       Despite a dreadful first half, the Tide gained 561 yards of total offense [school record tenth 500+ total this season] earned 21 first downs, and converted 3 of 5 third downs. The offense also lost a fumble in the fist half, thus ending a promising drive, but scored a touchdown on each of five possessions in the second half.

Tua completed 18 of his 22 pass attempts for 340 yards and 3 TDs. His 3 TD passes in the game brought his season total to 31, surpassing A.J. McCarren for the school record of touchdown passes in a season. Jalen completed 3 of 4 pass attempts for 31 yards and a TD.

Henry Ruggs, III was the leading receiver with 114 yards on 6 receptions. Jaylen Waddle caught 6 passes for 90 yards and 2 TDs. Jerry Jeudy added 77 yards on 6 receptions. Irv Smith, Jr.’s aforementioned ankle-breaking run resulted in a 68 yard TD. Josh Jacobs and DeVonta Smith rounded out the list of Tide players who caught passes.

Damien Harris was the lead rusher with 83 yards on 7 runs. He left the game after landing head first at the end of a 73 yard run. He did not return to the game, and as I write this set of The Grades, I have not seen any report on his condition. Najee Harris contributed 51 yards on 4 carries. Tua gained 37 yards on 4 rushes, and Ronnie Clark netted 14 yards on 3 runs. All total, Alabama gained 190 net yards rushing.

The Tide had seven sustained drives [80, 86, 72, 85, 63, 80, 55] that produced 6 TDs and a field goal. You might be thinking the overall grade is too low. I don’t know any other way to emphasize how poorly the offense played in the first half, where it only had four possessions and the drive chart reads: “TD, Punt, Fumble, FG”.

Defense:          C-          The Citadel gained 275 yards total offense; all on the ground. The Dogs earned 13 first downs, converted 6 of 17 third downs, held the ball for 36:23, and scored 17 points. Twice the Dogs were able to convert 4th down attempts. The Dogs’ running back Dante Smith gashed the Tide defense for 130 net yards.

Anfernee Jennings was the leading tackler with 11 stops and scored on a fumble recovery. Mack Wilson made 9 tackles, Deionte Thompson recorded 8 stops while LaBryan Ray and Dylan Moses each recorded 7 stops. The defense recorded 5 tackles for lost yardage and forced a fumble which I was recovered for a touchdown.

Special Teams:

Punting:            C        Mike Bernier only punted once for 34 yards. The coverage unit allowed a 4 yard return.  Jaylen Waddle slipped on what could have been a big return. Instead, the Tide realized no yards returning punts.

Place Kicking:             F          Two missed PATs. 

Kickoffs:                      F          A lost fumble on a kick return.

Coaching:                B-         Sixty-two players saw action in the game. None of them were ready to play at the opening kickoff. Some late-game personal foul penalties were dealt with very quickly by the staff as soon as the offending players reached the bench. The kicking game continues to be …. well …. “atrocious” is a word I haven’t used in a while but seems a fitting description. Saban did make a personnel change after the second failed PAT.

Well, enough is enough. Twenty four hours is far too long to celebrate beating The Citadel. This year’s Iron Bowl presents all kinds of opportunities: for a perfect regular season, for revenge, for an important milestone on the Road to 18, for a rational universe.

Alabama vs Auburn is not just some run-of-the-mill rivalry. It is the struggle between Gog and Magog; between light and darkness; between culture and agriculture.  Practice hard this week, Y’all. Put in the extra time in the film room (if you don’t have a film room, YouTube has hours of Tide highlights). Stay focused. Give thanks on Thursday for your families, your faith, your freedoms, and being a Tide fan.

Drive safe. See Y’all in Tuscaloosa!

Roll Tide, Y’all.

The Commissioner 

       

TO COMMENT ON THIS POST, PLEASE CLICK ON THE ABOVE LINK.

Mississippi State Grades

The four weeks between the LSU game and the first Saturday in December is National Dog Training Month.

Well, maybe not from sea to shining sea, but certainly in the State of Alabama. Of the Tide’s four opponents during that stretch three are bulldogs. So as a public service to the readers of The Commissioners Blog here are some answers to important questions directly from the internet on how to teach a bulldog to behave with translation into football-speak in parenthesis:

Q: What is the easiest way to train a dog?

A: Put him on a leash. (Shut down the running game.)

Q: In what order should I teach my dog commands?

A: Start with “sit”, then move to the more complicated tasks of “down”, “stay”, and finally “don’t touch.” (Control the line of scrimmage. Keep Tua’s jersey clean; give him time in the pocket.)

Q: How can I get my dog to calm down in the house?

A: Ignore your dog if he is too energetic or out of control. (Don’t retaliate when they get chippy; the retaliation always draws the flag.) Take beaks during play. (Keep possession of the ball, control the pace of the game, use the clock wisely, and get their fans out of the game.)

Q: How do you discipline a dog?

A: Distract, scruff-shake, isolation, squirt bottles (The first three require no translation. I think the team’s squirt bottles are best used during time outs for on-field hydration and it would probably be a 15 yard penalty if a trainer squirted an opposing player, so let’s just ignore that one.)

The first of the Tide’s three sessions of teaching good behavior to bulldogs resulted in a 24-0 win over Alabama’s oldest rival. For weeks I have been quietly worried about Mississippi State. The Starkville Bulldogs have a very fine defense, and an offense through nine games that had rushed for more than 2000 yards and scored 19 rushing touchdowns. The Puppies defense averaged allowing only 14 points per game.

Alabama plays State the week after LSU. That game is always physical. Consequently, MSU catches Alabama coming off a tough game and is able to keep the score close. Add to that mix the 2018 Bulldogs’ particular strengths and you have a recipe for at best a struggle win. To beat the Dogs by 24 in a shutout, is a respectable accomplishment. As much as I would have liked to see Bama score one more touchdown on its final drive rather than turning the ball over on downs at the MSU 1 yard line, a score of 31-7 would be less satisfying than notching a second consecutive shutout of a top-25 ranked team; the first such accomplishment in program history.

The Tide’s game plan was well-conceived. Rather than relying on Tua to light up the scoreboard with an up-tempo passing attack, Alabama chose to rely on its stable of excellent running backs. It was Alabama, not Mississippi State, smashing the opposing D Line, moving the chains, and draining the clock. Bama was up by two TDs at the end of the first quarter and had 21 points at the half.

State made some gap adjustments on defense during intermission, and the second half turned into a struggle of attrition. In the fourth quarter, Bama tacked on a 49 yard field goal,  then engineered a 10 play, 54 yard drive, consuming 6:18 effectively ending the game.

There were few electrifying moments in the passing game, although Josh Jacobs took a screen pass 14 yards for the Tide’s second touchdown. The running game, however, was brutally effective. The Defense on the other hand, turned in a second consecutive “Statement Game.” Pundits no longer blather the trope about the 2018 defense being a qualitative drop-off. If defenses win championships, it is safe to say the Tide defense are now playing like champions.

Here is how I grade the game:

Offense:           B          Alabama gained 305 yards of total offense [142 net rushing], earned 23 first downs, converted 4 of 12 third downs, and possessed the ball for 33:55 of the game [10:43 in the first stanza and 9:34 in the final].

Tua completed 14 of 21 pass attempts for 164 yards and one TD [Jacobs]. He was intercepted once and left the game in the third quarter after taking a helmet to his right leg, above the brace. The State player was clearly going for Tua’s knee. Thankfully, his aim was high. Mac Jones played the rest of the way and completed 3 of 6 attempted passes for a net loss of 1 yard.

Opposing defenses have figured out the only way to defend Tide receivers is grab their jerseys as soon as the ball is snapped and hang on through the play. They will keep employing this …. “Technique” ….until officials start calling pass interference. I will not hold my breath waiting for the Zebras to experience this Epiphany. Jerry Jeudy was the Tide leading receiver with 45 yards on 6 catches. Irv Smith, Jr. caught 5 balls for 70 yards. Jaylen Waddle has solidified his position in the rotation and added 26 yards on 3 receptions. A total of 5 different players caught passes.

Josh Jacobs had an outstanding game. Not only did he take a screen pass 14 yards for a touchdown. He added 97 rushing yards on 20 runs [4.8 avg]. Damien Harris carried the ball 14 times for 53 yards. Najee Harris ran the ball 3 times and gained 16 yards. Tua ran the ball 8 times, but half of those were sacks; accordingly, his 15 yards gained rushing netted out to a loss of 24 yards.

Alabama had only three sustained drives [73, 83, 54] resulting in two TDs and a turnover on downs at the MSU 1. The Tide’s third TD came on a short field thanks to recovery of a muffed punt at the MSU 27. MSU held Alabama to three possessions of three and out.

Defense:          A+.          MSU gained only 169 yards of total offense [44 net rushing]. The Dogs had seven possessions ending in three and out, and mounted only a single drive that gained 40 or more yards [51] which resulted in a missed FG.

Quinnen Williams [RS Soph.; DL; 6-4, 289; Birmingham] made 6 tackles [4 solo; 2 TFL]. Dylan Moses [Soph.; LB; 6-3, 233; Baton Rouge, La.] was also credited with 6 stops. Xavier McKinney, Raekwon Davis, Mack Wilson, and Isaiah Buggs were each credited with 5 tackles. Tide defenders made 10 tackles for lost yardage including 5 sacks, broke up 4 passes and hurried Nick Fitzgerald 3 times.

Think about this: Except for Isaiah Buggs, each of the individual defenders mentioned by name in the preceding paragraph are eligible to return to play for the Tide in 2019.

Several times Tide defenders were in position to intercept but did not manage to finish the takeaway.  

Special Teams:

Place Kicking:             A+       The play of the game was Joseph Bulovas kicking a 49 yard field goal. He was also perfect on each of his 3 PATs.

Punting:                      A+.       Walk-on graduate transfer Mike Bernier averaged 36.6 yards per punt on 5 punts. He landed 1 inside the Bulldog 20. The coverage team allowed no returns, and recovered a fumbled punt at the MSU 14. The Offense converted the turnover into a TD, so the fumble recovery was a good as a return for a score.

Kickoffs:                     B+.         Bulovas averaged 57.4 yards per kick on 5 kickoffs. One sailed out of bounds. Two were touchbacks. Josh Jacobs (who else?) returned one kick for 27 yards. The coverage team allowed only a single return for 12 yards.

Coaching:                    A.            Is someone in the Mal Moore complex reading The Grades? Last week I wrote the coaching grade would not be worthy of an A until the kicking woes were addressed. Well ….. it’s hard to argue they have not been. At the same time, however, I am still not taking penalties into account. Although the Tide did not suffer a single penalty, the quality of officiating in the game was, shall we say, not up to any acceptable standard. (However, put me in the category of folks like the MSU press box coaches who saw the football in Damien Harris' right hand when his knee when down. That's not a fumble, Gary! I would be more supportive of Danielson's critique of SEC officiating if it were not one-sided. With Gary, the refs are worthy of on-air criticism only when their screw-ups benefit Alabama. Can someone please hurry up and invent an app that allows you to listen to Eli Gold while watching the CBS broadcast without a 30 second delay?) The participation report lists 49 players who saw action in the game.

Alabama has a rendezvous scheduled with the silver-britches-wearing Bulldogs in the SEC CG. Those canines whipped the Villagers 27-10 between the hedges Saturday night. The CG however is two games, including the Iron Bowl away.

Although hating Auburn never goes out of season, the coaches, players, and fans must not overlook the scrappy Bulldogs of The Citadel, who come to Tuscaloosa this weekend.

Several months ago, I was chatting with a very well-respected retired colleague, who received his commission in the Infantry in the mid 1960’s from the military college of South Carolina. He was chastising me over the fact Alabama had never played The Citadel in football. “How can Alabama claim to be so good at football when it’s never played The Citadel?”, he asked.

“Because a game against The Citadel is one Alabama can never afford to lose,” I replied.

Well, this weekend Alabama has the opportunity, and challenge, of putting a check next to that particular box on its football resume. At the University of Alabama, teaching Bulldogs to behave is really important. Heck, we even sing about it.

As Coach Saban says, it does not matter who our opponent is. Alabama should strive to play its best every week. Bulldogs are Bulldogs. Get the leash ….

Roll Tide Y’all.

The Commissioner. 

TO COMMENT ON THIS POST, PLEASE CLICK ON THE ABOVE LINK.